User login

Join The Debate

Cast your vote and join the conversation.

Membership is free.


Get Started

You are here

Twilight of American Jewry

Twilight of American Jewry

Two sides debated the proposition that the American elites are to blame for Trump’s rise. Arguing in favor of the proposition were two Christian journalists – Tim Carney and Ben Domenech.

 

Arguing against it were two Jewish journalists – Bret Stephens (a former Jerusalem Posteditor-in-chief) and Jennifer Rubin.

 

Both Rubin and Stephens voiced their support for Clinton’s controversial assertion that half of Trump’s supporters are deplorable, unworthy of attention, un-American and irredeemable.

 

For their part, Domenech and Carney argued that Stephens and Rubin were ignoring the social and economic dislocation of the lower middle class. They argued that the suffering of members of this group has caused millions of Americans to feel betrayed by their political elites and turn to Trump to put a stop to a political game they believe is rigged against them.

 

Two-thirds of the way through the event, Carney brought up religion.