User login

Join The Debate

Cast your vote and join the conversation.

Membership is free.


Get Started

Warning message

  • The subscription service is currently unavailable. Please try again later.
  • The subscription service is currently unavailable. Please try again later.
Debates / Upcoming Debates
America Is Retreating from Global Leadership
Hosted By John Donvan
Wednesday, January 26, 2022 - 17:00 to 18:30
Add to Calendar
Streaming Live in 00d : 00h : 00m : 00s
Wednesday, January 26, 2022
05:00 PM − 06:30 PM EST
Request a Ticket
Have a question? Ask us
Upcoming Debate January 26, 2022
America Is Retreating from Global Leadership

It’s been a year of the Biden administration. And for many around the world, the question is simple: Can America still lead like it used to? Many who recall the era after the fall of the Berlin Wall remember Washington as both powerful and ascendant. The world’s only superpower boasted a level of military and economic supremacy seldom seen in the modern day. And that juggernaut was coupled with a clear and abundant desire to influence the global order. Things, in many ways, have changed. With China’s competitive rise, a revanchist Russia exercising greater influence in eastern Europe, and American retrenchment in places like Afghanistan and Syria, the role of U.S. leadership is less clear. President Biden, following his predecessor's “America First” policy, promised to “restore the soul of America.” Many took that to mean Washington was looking to re-cement its role as the pre-eminent global leader. But some say that ship has sailed, and question whether the tables are decidedly turning. In light of this emerging divide, we debate this question: Is America retreating from global leadership?

 
About The Debaters
For The Motion
An image of Mary Beth Long
Mary Beth Long − Fmr. Assistant Secretary of Defense, International Security Affairs
Mary Beth Long is an attorney, political advisor, and former government official. She was the first woman to be... read bio
An image of Bill Kristol
Bill Kristol − Founder and Editor-at-large of The Weekly Standard
Bill Kristol has been a leading participant in American political debates and a widely respected analyst of American... read bio
Against The Motion
An image of Kori Schake
Kori Schake − Director of Foreign and Defense Policy at American Enterprise Institute
Kori Schake is a senior fellow and the director of foreign and defense policy studies at the American Enterprise... read bio
An image of Vikram Singh
Vikram Singh − Senior Advisor, United States Institute of Peace
Vikram J. Singh is senior advisor to the Asia Program at the United States Institute of Peace (USIP). Singh has been... read bio
Main Points
For The Motion
  • The United States has made a series of foreign policy blunders that are impossible to overlook. Notably, the messy withdrawal from Afghanistan built up by decades of poor policy choices has left allies looking elsewhere for security.  
  • The rise of China and other powerful actors on the global stage diminishes America's preeminence in international relations. This has only been exacerbated by the pandemic and a global recession; America's inability to resist or recover from the effects has negatively affected how it is viewed across the world. 
  • The weakening of democracy at home has other countries turning elsewhere for examples of leadership. 
Against The Motion
  • Despite notable examples that get significant media attention, the fundamentals of America's position as a global leader have not changed. The United States is still an economic, military, and diplomatic powerhouse. 
  • Simply because other countries such as China and Russia are gaining influence and performing well economically does not mean the United States has lost its influence on the international stage. As a prominent example of democracy, the United States has maintained its position as a beacon of innovation and economic excellence. 
  • Though the United States may have 'led' the charge of democratic states in foreign policy interventions, the world is shifting in what it considers a global leader to be. The United States is moving with this shift toward securing alliances and partnerships that are a hallmark of true leadership.