User login

Join The Debate

Cast your vote and join the conversation.

Membership is free.

Get Started

You are here


Blame Big Pharma for Out-of-Control Health Care Costs

Back To Debate
Download Transcript
Live Transcript
  • Volley Round: Getting Your Money's Worth

    Clip: Debaters Ezekiel Emanuel, Paul Howard, Lori Reilly, and Neera Tanden point out the flaws in their opponents' arguments.

  • Transparency in Drug Pricing

    Clip: Debaters Neera Tanden, Paul Howard, Ezekiel Emanuel, and Lori Reilly discuss the potential for greater transparency in drug pricing and drug costs based on value.

  • Drug Prices and Cost Sharing

    Clip: Debaters Lori Reilly and Ezekiel Emanuel discuss how much consumers are paying for prescription drugs relative to other health care costs.

Debate Details

Health care costs in the U.S. are some 18 percent of GNP, nearly double what other rich countries spend. We read of drug therapies that cost $100,000 a year or more, and of drug price increases that are 6 times the rate of inflation, on average, and often much more when mergers reduce competition in the industry. Is this a major driver of excessive health care costs? Or is it a by-product of the huge costs of getting new drugs approved? Has big pharma delivered drugs that reduce the need for costly surgeries, which extend life and improve its quality? Or do they deserve the blame that has been leveled against them?

This debate is presented In Partnership with the Adam Smith Society, a project of the Manhattan Institute. The Adam Smith Society is a nationwide, chapter-based association of MBA students and business leaders who work to promote on campus debate and discussion about the moral, social, and economic benefits of capitalism.
IQ2US health care debates are 
also generously supported by Thomas Campbell Jackson

The Debaters

For the motion

Dr. Ezekiel J. Emanuel

Bioethicist & Vice Provost for Global Initiatives, University of Pennsylvania

Ezekiel J. Emanuel, M.D., is an oncologist, author, and a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress. He was founding chair of the Department... Read More

Neera Tanden

President and CEO, Center for American Progress

Neera Tanden is the president and CEO of the Center for American Progress and the Center for American Progress Action Fund. Tanden has served in both... Read More

Against the motion

Lori Reilly

Executive VP for Policy, Research, and Membership, PhRMA

Lori M. Reilly is executive vice president for policy, research and membership at the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America (PhRMA)... Read More

Paul Howard

Director of Health Policy, Manhattan Institute

Paul Howard is a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, director of health policy, and a member of Project FDA, an MI initiative. He is a contributor... Read More

Where Do You Stand?

For The Motion
  • Medical patent laws created to spur innovation distort the drug market to allow large pharmaceutical companies a monopoly on life-saving treatments and the ability to exploit those in need for monetary gain. 
  • Due to a lack of transparency around drug production costs and insurance subsidies for buyers, pharmaceutical companies are not beholden to traditional market forces like consumer-imposed price limits. 
  • Pharmaceutical companies can charge exorbitant prices for common drugs, even when the actual cost of drug production and distribution are low.
  • Because most developed nations regulate medical costs and allow state negotiation with drug companies, patients in the United States pay substantially more for pharmaceuticals than do their counterparts around the world.  
Against The Motion
  • Developing life-saving medication requires substantial time and resources; those costs are justifiably passed along to consumers when a drug is viable, and the sale of common drugs subsidizes the development of cures for rare diseases. 
  • Given the financial interests of for-profit insurance companies, hospitals, and medical practices, pharmaceutical companies cannot be blamed for the economic burdens of an out-of-control health care system. 
  • Pharmaceutical innovation eliminates the need for other costly medical interventions, such as organ transplants made obsolete by drug alternatives, and makes health care less expensive as a whole. 
  • Because the American government allows a competitive free market for drugs and does not stifle innovation, the world benefits from American research and development of drugs. 

This vote is intended to capture your opinions before hearing tonight’s debate.

Cast Your Vote

This vote is intended to capture your opinions after hearing tonight’s debate.

Cast Your Vote

Before you cast your vote, share some information with us:

{{ errors.first('email') }}

{{ errors.first('first name') }}

{{ errors.first('last name') }}

Are you sure?

{{ currentQuestion }} of {{ questions.length }}

Are you sure?

Are you sure?

{{ currentQuestion }} of {{ questions.length }}

Are you sure?

Review your answers below:

: {{ preVote[i] }}

Review your answers below:

: {{ postVote[i] }}

Please enjoy the debate and come back afterwards to cast your Post-Debate vote

Tell Us More

Before you cast your final vote, please tell us how you watched the debate

I listened to the podcast or read the transcript.
I watched it online.
I attended the debate live.
I haven't seen it yet.

Tell us why you changed your mind:

For the Motion Against the Motion Undecided
For the Motion Against the Motion Undecided

: {{ preVote[i] }}

: {{ postVote[i] }}

Donate to IQ2US

Thank you for joining us! Enter your email address below to receive the post-debate analysis and debate updates from IQ2US.

Learn About Voting
IQ2US debates are designed to expose audiences to civilized debate featuring opposing points of view. Please vote with your most genuine opinion.


  • Live Audience
  • Online Audience
  • Results
  • Breakdown

The Research

The Research

Holding Drug Companies Accountable for Drug Prices

January 20, 2016

Drug prices are out of control. No one really disputes it, and the real question is: Do we have the political will to do anything about it?

To Lower Drug Prices, Innovate, Don’t Regulate

September 23, 2015

Price control advocates argue that curtailing profits in the pharmaceutical industry would save the country money without reducing innovation. There is, however, no such thing as a free lunch. Bureaucratic price manipulation would only hurt the sickest patients.

Prescription Drugs’ Sizable Share of Health Spending

Drew Altman
December 13, 2015

Depending on what you count and how you count, drug spending may be an even larger problem than many thought. It clearly is for employers, who foot a large share of the nation’s health-care bills.

Please choose what best describes why this comment is being flagged:

The Discussion

or and Join the Conversation
Load More Comments